20070703

when should Justice bow to mercy?


An interesting question in ethics concerns the relationship between justice and mercy.  Today President Bush commuted a sentence for Scooter Libby, whom has been convicted and sentenced to 30 months in Prison for breaching National Security.  The White House made their announcement after a final appeal was denied.  Is this use of Presidential Power justified?  Justice requires its execution and some would argue that justice has not been served until judgments are carried through.  One is apt to hastily jump to the judgement that this most recent display of executive power reveals a grave error in the current administration.



Yet what about mercy? Is not mercy more perfect an expression of justice than the blind execution of judgments?  Every expression of mercy in human conduct, if it truly be merciful, will not disintigrate justice but rather perfect and fulfill it.  Mercy completes justice where justice cannot complete itself.



Yet even if we accept that mercy is the fulfillment of justice, how do we know that The Bush Administration is not simply corrupt?  Or better put, how are we to know that the pardon was merciful?  Human beings have many reasons for the things they do; for example, what if the pardon was given in order to repay an old debt?  That would certainly be an unjust pardon.  We need not even imagine that mercy must accompany a "merciful act".



Uniquely, mercy can only be granted by whom the debt of justice is owed.  Mercy is unique in the fashion,



20070701

what is philosophy?


People often forget that our words are what link us to the past - to former generations, antiquated cultures, and our own history.  The language we use in our ordinary lives has been bequethed upon us by those who came before us.  Some of our words come from medieval france, others from 6th Century Arabia, or 3rd Century Africa.  You see, when a new word goes into common circulation, what circulates is a new idea, conception, or way of looking at things.  A culture will gain and lose words through time as certain ideas or conceptions go out of circulation.  In like fashion, our ideas and conceptions change over time.  For example, the English languiage is significantly smaller today than it was seven hundred years ago.  Ironically, our language is itself an intellectual heritage.  Often it is helpful to bear this fact of heritage in mind when we ask questions like 'what is philosophy'?.