20050419

On Atheism

It is true that God is a concept, insofar as it has a linguistic grammar. But, this does not mean there is no Other. BUT Other is an empty concept. It applies to both everything and nothing simultaneously. And what's more: the logical grammar is structured so that it will remain empty. The Concept God, though limited and self-defunctory (in that in its grammar remains finite [the form of the concept has invalidated the content]), has a grammar so as to attempt an articulation of the Other. Thus we must conclude that "God" has a self-deficient meaning and must be delegated to the science:theology. BUT the concept of Other still remains. The entire history of thought can be interpreted as an attempt to articulate Other-ness. Thus, the historical function of the concept God has not been invalidated. We can no longer speak of God, but only Otherness; this Otherness maintains the ancient grammar of mysticism we see being used in the Early Christian thought. So the atheist must ask: does the question of Otherness invalidate this negation of theism? If so, then the grammar of Otherness will redistribute theology (for: Aristotle: the primary science informs the content of all the lower sciences) but the science remains. The mystical grammar of "God" is identically empty to Other. Thus, atheism must logically deduce that there is no Other. This cannot be done. Other is both empty and full simultaneously.

"Atheism" and "Theism" have a circular relationship. (and only fools rattle on about vulgar v benign circles of thought) These two concepts are (two) species of a greater genus. This genus is the concept of Other.

BUT: Does Other simply recreate the defunct grammatical malfunction of "God"?

No: Otherness implies plurality: this means that the concept does not imply ~finitude; it implies rather finitude. BUT: this plurality further demands universality. [the stagirite unfolds this grammar in his eighth aporia. "Finite" and "Universal" have a perpendicular relationship; infinitude is not implied. Because of this: the concept's form is retained as logical (vis. the concept no longer demands a form:~finite to account for content:~finite [~finite = "Infinite"]).
Concpt:Other > does not have a grammar identical to Concept:God. We have not simply recreated the defunctory grammar of the Concept:God.

Question: But how exactly does this defeat the aim of C:Atheism?

Answer: The aim of C:Atheism is given by its name "anti-theism" which equals ~atheism. The logical grammar therefore dictates a negation of theism (that is, the negation of the logical grammar of God). This negation is nothing other than a grammatical marker concerning the logical function of the concept. In such a way, we can see that there is something of a circular relationship betweenC:Atheism & C:God, such that the grammar of the two - once interconnected - are seen to be a grammatical species of a greater genus: the concept of Other. Thus the Atheistic aim of proving a logical contradiction in the concept:God rather implies a grammatical structure of Other which also includes a concept:God. C:Other is the genus for (C:G<->C:A).

And what is striking is that the mystical concept of God is identical to the concept of Other. we have confirmed the possibility of a theological science. But the problem is that it is no longer a science of theism, but rather a science of Other.

Later it will be shown that the study of Being is connected to the study of Other: It is the interconnection between the study of the c:I and c:Other. This is because the grammar of Being is required for both (C:I & C:Other). Being is therefore a fundamental; which is to say that it has a logical grammar required for all concepts. It is one of the building blocks of thought itself. We might even say that it is one of the binaries.

__________________
KEY: ~ = negation
> = therefore
<-> = if and only if
: = connector
C= concept
S = species
G = genus

HINT: Always remember that logical notation opperates like a computer system
__________________

Further Topics:
1. Pantheism
2. C: Nothingness
3. The subspecies of form:universal

No comments: